Max Holloway’s recent pivot to the lightweight division comes on the heels of a shocking defeat to champion Ilia Topuria at UFC 308, marking the first knockout loss in his storied career. With a resume boasting 26 victories and renowned battles against top-level fighters, including a thrilling last-second knockout win against Justin Gaethje at UFC 300, Holloway’s trajectory has been nothing short of impressive. However, his sudden shift back to lightweight, particularly his immediate desire to engage in a trilogy against Dustin Poirier, raises questions regarding the wisdom of such a bold move.
Given Holloway’s recent experiences at featherweight, where he has faced elite competition like Alexander Volkanovski, it is understandable that fans and commentators alike are curious about his next steps. Daniel Cormier, a former two-division champion, voiced particular concern over Holloway’s rapid transition into the lightweight fray, suggesting that the UFC should consider a more measured approach—one that allows “Blessed” to regain his footing before facing the division’s top-tier fighters again.
Cormier’s suggestion to ease Holloway into the lightweight realm through potentially less formidable opponents is well-grounded. With fighters like Michael Chandler or Rafael Fiziev on the roster, Cormier proposes matchups that could allow Holloway to acclimatize to the new weight class without the immediate pressures of fighting a known adversary like Poirier or another elite fighter.
The rationale behind this approach is clear: moving up in weight class can be a daunting task, especially against seasoned veterans who have finely honed their skills in that division. Recent history illustrates that many fighters struggle during their transitions, often resulting in disappointing performances. By taking on less dangerous opponents first, Holloway can build confidence and potentially reclaim his status as a contender in lightweight.
While a bout against someone like Poirier—or even Justin Gaethje—may highly excite fans due to the rivalry and their previous encounters, it might not serve Holloway’s long-term interests. The lightweight division is replete with explosive talent, and stepping directly into the spotlight against established fighters could lead to further setbacks for a fighter of Holloway’s caliber.
Additionally, engaging in fights against rising stars such as Benoit Saint Denis or Paddy Pimblett could not only invigorate Holloway’s career but also introduce fresh narratives to the lightweight title picture. These matchups could galvanize fan interest while allowing Holloway to rebuild his momentum, thereby positioning him for a more favorable run at the title in the future.
Max Holloway’s career has been marked by incredible highs and gut-wrenching lows. Adopting a thoughtful strategy as he moves into lightweight could significantly enhance his chances of long-term success. By seeking bouts that prioritize recovery and skill development rather than immediate championship glory, Holloway can craft a more sustainable path to reclaiming his place among the elite in the UFC.